Will I lose my Google rankings if I redesign my website?

By Kate Dole · Published

A new website shouldn't cost you the customers who already find you on Google. Most of the risk sits in a few boring steps that are easy to skip, so here's the checklist I work from, before design, on launch day and in the first week.

You keep your Google rankings through a redesign when every old page address redirects to its new home and the words that answered people’s questions stay on the page. Rankings drop when addresses vanish, useful text gets cut, or the words only load through scripts. Google’s own guide says to expect some temporary movement, and that a medium-sized site can take “a few weeks or more” to settle. Make the redirect map before design starts.

Here’s how it usually goes wrong. The new site goes live on a Friday, everyone loves it, and three weeks later someone notices the calls that used to come from Google have gone quiet. Nothing is broken, exactly. Every page Google knew about just leads to “page not found” now. All of that is avoidable, and most of it is boring, which is why it gets skipped.

Everything below comes from Google’s site move documentation (last updated August 2026) and from how I run launches for small businesses around Moncton. If you’re still deciding what a new site should cost, start with how much does a website cost in New Brunswick? and come back here when you have a launch date.

Why do rankings drop after a redesign?

Because Google ranked your old pages, and a redesign can quietly make those pages disappear. Four things cause most of the damage.

Addresses that vanish. Your old services page lived at one URL. The new site puts it somewhere else, or merges it into the homepage, and nobody tells Google. Every link pointing at the old address, from your Google profile, a Chamber directory, a newspaper story from 2019, now lands on a “page not found”.

Words that get cut. The page that brought in most of your visitors probably answered a question in plain words: what you do, where, for whom, and roughly what it costs. A redesign tends to trade that text for a big photo and a five-word headline. It looks cleaner and gives Google much less to go on.

Text that only exists after scripts run. Some builders and some custom builds send the browser an almost empty page and fill in the words with JavaScript. Google attempts to render pages, but its own redirect guide warns that “rendering may fail for various reasons” (Google Search Central, redirects). I build so the words are in the page itself from the first load.

Leftovers from the staging site. A “don’t index this” setting that made sense while the new site was private, and then went live with it. Google’s guide reminds you to remove “any noindex or robots.txt blocks that were only needed for the migration.”

What’s a redirect map, and do I need one?

A redirect map is a two-column list: every old page address on the left, its new home on the right. It’s the least glamorous document in the whole project, and the one I’d grab first in a fire. You need one if any old page gets visits, which for an established business is almost always.

Google’s guide is direct about it: “It’s important to map your old site’s URLs to the URLs for the new site.” It recommends “server side permanent redirects from the old URLs to the new URLs,” meaning 301 or 308 redirects, which tell Google a page has moved for good. It also says to keep them “for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year.”

Two rules from the same guide catch people out:

  • Send each old page to its closest match. Redirecting everything to the new homepage confuses visitors, and Google says it “might be treated as a soft 404 error.” If you merged three old pages into one, it’s fine to point all three at the merged page.
  • Avoid chains. Old page to newer page to newest page slows everything down. Point each old address straight at its final home.

Here’s what a small map looks like:

Old addressNew addressNote
/services.html/services/Same content, new layout
/our-team/about/Merged into the About page
/contact-us.php/contact/Same page, new platform
/blog/2019-spring-sale/blog/Retired post, sent to the nearest page

To find your old addresses, pull your top pages from the Performance report in Search Console and add everything in your old sitemap. If you’ve never set up Search Console, your current website platform can usually export a page list.

Can a redesign make my site harder for ChatGPT to read?

Yes, in much the same ways it can for Google. OpenAI says plainly that “sites that are opted out of OAI-SearchBot will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers” (OpenAI, crawlers). A new site that ships with a stricter robots.txt can drop out of ChatGPT search without anyone noticing.

The script problem matters here too. I can’t count on every AI tool running JavaScript the way a browser does, so I treat the page’s HTML as the version that has to carry the answer: your services, your town, your prices if you publish them, written as text.

Check two things before launch. First, that your robots.txt on the new site still allows the search crawlers you want (Googlebot, Bingbot, OAI-SearchBot). Second, that your key pages still read sensibly with scripts switched off. I go deeper on the ChatGPT side in how do I get my business recommended by ChatGPT?

What goes on the launch checklist?

Work through it in three passes. The first happens weeks before the site goes live.

Before design

  • Export every current page address from Search Console and your old sitemap.
  • Note your ten most-visited pages, and save a copy of each page’s text.
  • Write the redirect map, with one closest match for every old address.
  • Decide what stays the same: the domain, ideally, and the addresses of your best pages.
  • Keep the words from your best-performing page as the starting draft for its replacement.

Launch day

  • Turn on the redirects and test them. Google suggests the URL Inspection tool for single addresses; I also click through the whole map by hand.
  • Remove any “noindex” setting left over from staging, and check robots.txt.
  • Update internal links so the new site points to new addresses, as Google’s guide recommends.
  • Submit the new sitemap in Search Console, then add the site and sitemap to Bing Webmaster Tools.
  • Update the website link on your Google Business Profile and anywhere else you control.

Week one

  • Watch Search Console for a spike in “Not found” errors. Google’s guide says it frequently sees people “redirecting to the wrong (non-existent) URLs on the new site.”
  • Run URL Inspection on any important page that seems to be missing.
  • Open the Generative AI performance report in Search Console. Google added it in June 2026 for impressions in AI Overviews and AI Mode, and rolled it out to all sites by August 31 (Google Search Central blog, 2026).
  • Open AI Performance in Bing Webmaster Tools. It launched as a public preview in February 2026 and shows how often your pages are cited in Microsoft Copilot and Bing’s AI summaries, and the phrases the AI used to find them (Bing Webmaster Blog, Feb 2026).
  • Ask the sites that link to you most to update their links. A redirect works, but a direct link is better.

How long until things settle?

Usually a few weeks for a small site, and sometimes longer. Google’s guide says that “a small to medium-sized website can take a few weeks for most pages to move,” that visibility “may fluctuate temporarily during the move,” and that “a site’s rankings will settle down over time.”

What that looks like in practice varies with the size of the site, how often Google crawls it, and how much changed. A dip in the first couple of weeks is normal and no reason to panic or start undoing things. (Step away from the undo button.) Steady “Not found” errors, or a key page that never comes back, are signs of something to fix. That’s what the week-one checks are for, and why I’d keep watching Search Console weekly for the first month or two.

What I’d do

Write the redirect map before anyone opens a design file. When I start a redesign, the old site’s page list is one of the first things I ask for, ahead of moodboards and colour. It shapes the new navigation, and it shows me which pages are quietly doing the work.

Then I keep the best page’s words almost as they are. I’ll rewrite the headline, tighten the paragraphs and fix whatever reads like a committee wrote it, but the sentences that answer real questions stay.

The sentences that already answer your customers’ questions are the part of the old site worth moving house with.

Google’s guide prefers one change at a time: new domain first, layout later. Most small businesses I work with can’t fund two projects, so I hold the domain still and keep the addresses of the best pages, and change the platform and design together. If you’re moving off an older WordPress install, is my WordPress site outdated? covers the decision, and is Framer a good choice for a small business website? covers where I usually build instead. You can see a full relaunch in the Foreword Films case study.

If your new site is already live and the redirects never happened, don’t despair. That’s a contained job, and a satisfying one to fix. For most small sites, the redirect map, the redirects and the Search Console and Bing setup fit in a Fixer day for the migration, which is $575.

Quick answers

Should I change my domain name at the same time?

Only if you have to. Google's site-move guide suggests making big changes one at a time, so if a new domain is coming, do it as its own step and keep the old one redirecting for at least a year.

Will moving from WordPress to Framer hurt my SEO?

The platform matters less than what happens to your addresses and your words. Map every old URL to a new one, carry the useful text across, and confirm your Framer plan includes redirects before launch day.

Do I lose my Google reviews if I redesign my website?

No. Your reviews belong to your Google Business Profile, which is separate from your website. Just update the website link on the profile if your address changes.

What does a redesign cost in New Brunswick?

My starter site is $1,500 for three pages, and a site of up to eight pages runs $5,000 to $8,000. The full breakdown, with other studios' published prices, is in my website cost guide.

Want to be seen?

Tell me what you're building and where it needs to show up. One conversation, one flat-rate quote.

Book a free call